News

Preserving Issues at Trial for Successful Appeals

When a criminal case goes to trial, every decision made by the judge, prosecutor, and defense attorney can influence the outcome. For defendants, the trial is not always the end of the story. If errors occur, a conviction can often be appealed. But to succeed on appeal, those errors must be properly preserved during the trial. Understanding how to protect appellate rights at every stage is one of the most important parts of a strong defense strategy.

Why Preserving Issues Matters

An appeal is not a new trial. The appellate court reviews what happened in the lower court to determine if legal errors affected the verdict or sentence. The appellate judges do not reexamine witnesses or reconsider the facts. Instead, they focus on whether the law was applied correctly.

If a defense attorney does not object to an error or raise a specific issue during trial, the appellate court may refuse to consider it later. This rule, known as “preservation,” prevents defendants from bringing up issues for the first time on appeal. In other words, to challenge a mistake later, the defense must make a record of it in the moment.

Common Examples of Preservation

Several critical moments in trial can determine whether an issue is preserved for appeal.

• Evidentiary rulings: If the prosecution introduces evidence that is irrelevant, prejudicial, or obtained unlawfully, the defense must object. Without that objection, the appellate court may consider the issue waived. 
• Jury instructions: Defense counsel must review proposed jury instructions and object to any that misstate the law. Incorrect instructions can form the basis of an appeal, but only if objections were raised before the jury deliberates. 
• Improper arguments: When a prosecutor makes an inflammatory or misleading statement, the defense should object immediately. Silence can signal agreement, making it harder to raise the issue later. 
• Sentencing errors: Even after a conviction, preservation continues. If a judge relies on inaccurate information or imposes an unlawful sentence, the defense must object or file a post-sentencing motion to preserve the claim. 

Building a Strong Record

Preservation is not just about objecting. It is about creating a record for the appellate court to review. This includes filing motions, making offers of proof, and ensuring that key exchanges are transcribed. Skilled defense attorneys know how to document every objection and ensure the trial transcript reflects their reasoning.

For example, if a judge excludes critical evidence, counsel should explain why that evidence matters. This creates a clear record showing how the exclusion harmed the defense. Without those details, appellate judges may assume the issue was minor or strategic.

The Role of Trial and Appellate Counsel

While many defense lawyers handle both trial and appeal, others specialize in one stage. Collaboration between trial and appellate counsel can be invaluable. Appellate attorneys bring a deep understanding of how higher courts interpret preservation rules. They can help ensure trial lawyers create a record that anticipates potential appellate issues.

Protecting Rights from Day One

Preserving issues is not something to think about after a conviction. It begins at arraignment, continues through pretrial motions, and extends into sentencing. Every stage presents opportunities to safeguard appellate rights.

At Glozman Law, we recognize that trials are unpredictable and high-stakes. Our attorneys combine courtroom skill with a deep knowledge of appellate strategy, ensuring every objection and motion serves a larger purpose. If you believe an error affected your case, contact us today to discuss how to protect your right to appeal.